Appeal Court Upholds Death Sentence on Hilton Hotel Owner, Adedoyin, Over OAU Student’s Murder
The Court of Appeal in Akure has upheld the death sentence imposed on Dr. Rahmon Adedoyin, the owner of Hilton Hotel, Ile-Ife, for the murder of Timothy Adegoke, a postgraduate student of Obafemi Awolowo University (OAU). This case, which has drawn significant public attention, highlights the tragic events surrounding Adegoke’s death and the subsequent legal proceedings.
Background of the Case
Timothy Adegoke was killed between November 5 and November 7, 2021, while staying at Hilton Hotel in Ile-Ife. The hotel, owned by Dr. Rahmon Adedoyin, became the focal point of the investigation. The Osun High Court found Adedoyin and two of his staff, Adeniyi Aderogba and Oyetunde Kazeem, guilty of conspiracy and unlawful killing, sentencing them to death by hanging in May 2023.
The case escalated to the Court of Appeal after Adedoyin challenged the lower court’s decision.
Court of Appeal’s Verdict
On January 23, 2025, the appellate court unanimously upheld the convictions of Adedoyin and his co-defendants on charges of conspiracy and unlawful killing. Justice Oyebisi Omoleye, who delivered the verdict, reinforced the lower court’s ruling, emphasizing the severity of the crime.
However, the appellate court made significant adjustments to the original judgment:
- Payment of School Fees: The court set aside the ruling requiring Adedoyin’s estate to pay for the education of the deceased’s children.
- Forfeiture Orders: The forfeiture of Hilton Hotel and the Hilux pickup used to transport Adegoke’s body was also nullified.
Legal Implications of the Judgment
The Court of Appeal adhered strictly to statutory provisions, limiting its scope to penalties outlined by the law. Counsel for the Osun State Government, represented by Fatima Adesina on behalf of Femi Falana, expressed satisfaction with the judgment, noting that the essential aspects of the lower court’s decision were upheld.
Overview of the Key Rulings
| Aspect | Lower Court Ruling | Appeal Court Ruling |
|---|---|---|
| Death Sentence | Upheld | Upheld |
| Responsibility for Children’s Education | Adedoyin’s estate liable | Set aside |
| Property Forfeiture | Hotel and Hilux forfeited to the government | Forfeiture order nullified |
Public and Legal Reactions
The judgment has reaffirmed the gravity of the crime while addressing concerns about the scope of penalties imposed. Legal experts have lauded the appellate court for its adherence to statutory limits, while the public continues to seek justice for Timothy Adegoke.
NYSC Corps Member Dies, Others Injured in Ebonyi Road Accident
Editor’s Note:
The upholding of the death sentence against Rahmon Adedoyin and his co-conspirators underscores the judiciary’s commitment to justice in cases of unlawful killings. However, the reversal of certain aspects of the lower court’s judgment demonstrates the complexity of balancing legal principles with public sentiment. The case remains a landmark in Nigeria’s judicial history, highlighting the need for accountability and the rule of law.
